1958 12 Hours of Sebring – Anglo-Americans and the Redhead

1958 12 Hours of Sebring – Anglo-Americans and the Redhead

1958 12 Hours of Sebring by Ed McDonoughStory and photos by Ed McDonough

1957 and 1958 were interesting years in international sports car racing, when it could be argued that sports cars turned into sports racing cars, in spite of efforts to make them more like what they started out to be! But higher windscreens were unlikely to achieve much!

It was clearly Ferrari vs. Maserati, with 290MMs from Ferrari beating the 300S from Maserati at Sebring, and then the 315S Ferrari took that tragic Mille Miglia. Aston Martin intervened at the Nurburgring and Jaguars swept Le Mans. The Maserati 450S took a win in Sweden, but Peter Collins and Phil Hill in a Ferrari 335S won in Venezuela and that gave the championship to Enzo Ferrari.

New rules appeared in 1958, and Maserati was on the brink of financial crisis, and had failed to develop the 300S for the new three-liter rules. At Buenos Aires in January, two new Ferrari 250 Testa Rossa entries in the hands of Hill/Collins and von Trips, Gendebien and Musso took the win. At Sebring the sleek new ‘redhead’ would do it again, and for the rest of the season, Aston Martin would be the only other team to get to the top of the podium.

Though 1958 would also begin to see the rise in favour of Grand Touring cars, the outright winners were always going to come from the new generation of racing sports cars. Ferrari had six of the Testa Rossas at Sebring, three private cars and three works machines for Hill/Collins, Musso/Gendebien and Mike Hawthorn/von Trips. The opposition would no longer come from Maserati…there were only two there and they were private entries…but from Aston Martin.

Aston Martin sent the DBR1 for Stirling Moss/Tony Brooks and Carroll Shelby/Roy Salvadori, and there was a GT entry of a DB2/4 MkIII for George Constantine and John Dalton. That car now belongs to John Goss and is alive and well and still racing! There were also some quick looking Jaguars though the Coventry firm products were a bit out-classed by now. There were Ecurie Ecosse D-Types for Ron Flockhart and Masten Gregory, and for Ninian Sanderson/Ivor Bueb, with a Cunningham car for Briggs himself and Walt Hansgen. Cunningham also entered two Lister-Jaguars for Ed Crawford and Indy driver Pat O’Connor, and Archie Scott Brown and Hansgen. The Jaguar-powered machines should have stayed home.

The entry list was indeed star-studded, though some of these stars had not quite risen yet. Dan Gurney was sharing a DB-Panhard with Howard Hanna, and he even found time to have some practice laps in the Fiat-Abarth Zagato entered for Denise McCluggage and Ruth Levy. How Dan managed to fit into either of these cars is a mystery! Jo Bonnier was brought in to increase the attractiveness of the Duncan/Hinkle Maserati. The two Americans both out-qualified the Swede who broke the gearbox in the race. Duncan and Hinkle were not impressed. John Fitch was sharing one of the private Ferrari Testa Rossas with Ed Hugus. Bob Holbert and Skip Hudson were in a Porsche 550RS, and veteran Bill Milliken was in an Elva with Millard Ripley and Cameron Argetsinger. There were Indy drivers Jim Rathmann and Pat O’Connor, and the Argentinean Alejandro DeTomaso was sharing an OSCA with his new wife Isabelle Haskell.

The start was something of a shambles, some drivers posed and ready to sprint to their cars, while others were still ambling across the circuit. This prompted one false start so everybody had to line up again.

This is what you might call a drivers’ meeting!
This is what you might call a drivers’ meeting!
Pre-Start #1 - The drivers begin to amble across the road.
Pre-Start #1 - The drivers begin to amble across the road.
Pre-Start #2 - Some drivers are ready, but Archie Scott Brown, 6th from right, adjusts his helmet, and seems to be losing his trousers.
Pre-Start #2 - Some drivers are ready, but Archie Scott Brown, 6th from right, adjusts his helmet, and seems to be losing his trousers.

The Augie Pabst/Jim Jeffords Corvette SR2 was expected to be quick off the line. Pabst was making his international race debut. Jeffords was indeed first off the line but a wheel problem stopped him out on the circuit and he was therefore last across the line at the end of the first lap. The Corvettes had made a big impact the previous year, but were not realising their promise. Juan Fangio had tried one in 1957 and gone much quicker than anyone else, though he was still faster in his Maserati.

The Aston Martins made the early bid for the lead with Stirling Moss going out in front. Mike Hawthorn had the works Ferrari second but Roy Salvadori had the other Aston on his tail and the British cars were looking very impressive. Roy then moved past Hawthorn to make it an Aston 1-2. The Listers were going well in the opening laps but Olivier Gendebien tried to force his way past Archie Scott Brown and managed to climb right up over the back of the Lister. The drivers hopped out and got the Ferrari off and it went back to the pits for repairs but the Lister was out. The second Lister only managed six laps before the engine went and all the Jaguar-powered cars were gone by lap 22.

Stirling Moss was off to an early lead in the Aston Martin DBR1.
Stirling Moss was off to an early lead in the Aston Martin DBR1.
Roy Salvadori in the Aston he shared with Shelby was third in the early stages.
Roy Salvadori in the Aston DBR1 he shared with Shelby was third in the early stages.
Archie Scott Brown’s Lister tangled with Gendebien’s Ferrari on only the 3rd lap. The Ferrari sat on top of the Lister, as the Brown/Yoland DB passed by. Gendebien recovered and finished 2nd.
Archie Scott Brown’s Lister (Chassis BHL101) tangled with Gendebien’s Ferrari 250 TR (Chassis 0726) on only the 3rd lap. The Ferrari sat on top of the Lister, as the Brown/Yoland DB passed by. Gendebien recovered and finished 2nd.
A real mixed bag. Salvadori in the Aston is hardly visible as he cuts through traffic. Number 3 is the 4.6 liter Corvette of Pabst and Jeffords, which only lasted 27 laps. The Bueb/Sanderson D-Type was gone 5 laps earlier, while the Constantine/Dalton Aston was gone at 15 laps.
A real mixed bag. Salvadori in the Aston DBR1 is hardly visible as he cuts through traffic. Number 3 is the 4.6 liter Corvette SR2 of Pabst and Jeffords, which only lasted 27 laps. The Bueb/Sanderson D-Type was gone 5 laps earlier, while the Constantine/Dalton Aston Martin DB2/4 was gone at 15 laps.
Ron Flockhart in the D-Type shared with Masten Gregory was another early Jaguar retirement.
Ron Flockhart in the D-Type shared with Masten Gregory was another early Jaguar retirement.

1 2 Next

Show Comments (41)

Your email address will not be published.

  1. Good stuff. Keep it coming. Ed McDonough must have a wonderful library of images and stories. Those guys that were actually their have a unique look back at history that the rest of us can only wish we had.

  2. One suggested correction of an often repeated mistake; Dan Gurney did not practice or race the DB with Howard Hanna. I have spoken with Dan and Howard’s son and they both confirmed that it did not happen. I have also corresponded with Denise McCluggage who did confirm that Dan did practice in her Fiat Abarth.

  3. Dennis and Tom:
    Thanks for the comments.
    Yes, I have a substantial photo archive which I continue to work on every day, and for some time have spent efforts finding and saving motor racing photos. I have a collection of some 5000 negatives that literally was fished out of a dust bin. And there is the widow of a well known Jaguar engineer of the ’50s who told me that…’no one would all that old stuff so i threw it out’ “It” was his life long collection of drawings, notes and photos of his work on competition Jaguars….so I try to prevent this in some small way.

    Re: Dan Gurney…I am pleased that is clarified now…I should have asked earlier. Many thanks.
    Ed McDonough

    1. Hi Ed – very exciting article and pics, congrats and thx! I own one of the Abarth Zagatos which was entered (#80) and driven by Dr. Harry Fry (longtime president of the Miami Sports Car Club). I was able to collect some picas and material of that race but am still searching and investigating to find more. In case you have pictures or other stuff related to either Harry Fry or his car it would be very interested! The very best from Switzerland, Renald.

  4. Ed –

    my hat is off to you for this article and your efforts to save motorsports history, and I imagine there are many invaluable items that have been lost to dustbins and trash piles. The Gurney/Hanna listing is repeated everywhere, so don’t feel bad…it is in virtually every race result I have ever seen. I only found out the error by contacting the Hanna family looking for photos of the car.

    If I can ever help your efforts in any way please let me know.



  5. The picture of the Jean Kunstle/Ken Miles Porsche 550 RS is great! Look beyond the car. Stacks of pipes! A specatator and his car! Possibly a marshall. In the foreground is a fire hydrant on the inside of a turn!! Love it. Whimps need not apply to drive one of those.

  6. Great story and photos of Sebring. We had a 50th annivsary for Elva there in 2008. Elva driver Rip Ripley came for the ocassion, as did the dauhter of Charles Kurtz (deceased.) The Elva driven by Wylie had a Climax FPF engine.

  7. God Bless , Ed McDonough. Thank you so very much for letting us drift back to a much simpler time, the GOLDEN Age of Sports Car Racing in America…. All the greats were present …… Ole Shell’s ticker was still good to geaux and Mr 1961 ” Phil Hill” was on still on his way up, to the TOP of the racing world. What a wonderful time to be alive. John Coltrane and Ms Billie Holiday were still alive and performing. You could buy a prototype Ferrari or Maserati or OSCA for under $ 20 thousand… and a new 1958 Custom color Fender Stratocaster and a Fender Amp would only set ya back $225 bucks.

    Thanks a bunch Ed, well done. Well done indeed.

  8. I was crew chief on the Martin,Baptista, Warren ELVA MK 111 and was in the garage during night practice when Doc Wylie
    went off course as he was exiting “Big Bend” about topped out in third gear. With the 1500 FPF the MK 111 was a bit tail light and Doc hit a guy wire at something over 100 MPH and cut the rear end of the car off just behind the cockpit. A differance of 6″ would have been very bad! It looked like someone had taken a saw to the car. Doc was one of the nicest guys racing and a real gentleman needless to say the garage was very subdued that evening.

    1. I spoke with Doc two years ago about Sebrin. His car was a MK III with the DOHC Climax. He said something broke in he back and he went between a telephone poll and its guide wire, and the back was cut off or4 neary so. The car went back to the UK where the FPF was put into a new MK IV and sold to Burdette Martin.

      1. I have seen several references that Dr. Wyllie’s car was a Mark II (like the photo caption) and several that say it was a Mark III. Is it definitly a Mark III?

        1. Doc’s Elva was a MK III made especially for the Sebring race. After the crash the car was returned to the UK and the FPF Climax put into an Elva MK IV that was bought by Berdie Martin. Berdie drove that car once or twice. BTW, the blue Elva driven by Charles Kurtz is a MK II. His daughter was at the Elva event at the 2008 vintage race at Sebring.

    2. Fred,


      By chance did you know FRANK CAMPBELL of Hinsdale, IL? In late 1957 he bought a red MK II that Burdette Martin owned. Campbell raced it at RA500 in 1958. I now have his MK II and have been trying to locate his descendants.

      [email protected]

  9. Terrific documentation of the ’58 event! Thanks for sharing this. As others have said, keep it coming. There is a real need for quality documents by people who where there with stories and photos.

    I’d love to see a story on the ’56 – 12 Hours of Sebring and photos. -Greg

  10. Hi Ed

    Great piece on the 58 Sebring 12 hour race. What a fabulous era of motor sport and thanks for bringing it all back to life for us. Thanks also for the shot which shows my Aston staying out of trouble (!) or is Constantine taking all 3 cars around the outside? I haven’t seen that photo before – any more?

    Quick question – the 1958 World Championship was for cars with 3 litres and under – Corvettes – special engines or special ‘American’ rules?

    All the best


  11. I wasn’t even aware of Sebring in 1958, but I really enjoyed your coverage. And yes, I do recognize the drivers mentioned and the cars of course. Thank you for the article and pictures.
    Tom Bucher

  12. Archie Scott Brown is either losing his pants as you said or he is wearing a weight lifting belt! Funny either way…

    Thank you for the fine article.

    1. I think you are right – most definitely a brace (like a weight lifting belt). As a result of German Measles during his mother’s pregnancy, Archie was born with severe disablement to his legs and right arm. Tremendous determination and several operations meant that Archie was able to lead a normal life, although he never grew over 5’0″ tall.

  13. Sebring 1958 Story
    Ed,I was at Sebring 1957 with my dad and Chas Addams( the cartoonist)and I clearly remember the convincing win by Jean Behra and Fangio Maserati 450 S (spectacular at night with the flames exiting the side gutterpipe exhausts as it thundered down the straight). and a fine 2nd OD by Stirling in the 300S( restored by me some years later and now with Tony Wang). Not Exactly a Ferrari day for the 290 MM ,but a Maserati slaughter.
    Cheers Stephen

    1. I found this old query about Sam Weiss…he was , for a time , a neighbor of my parents when I was a boy. I had some memorable experiences with him and later in life , after his demise, began researching and following his racing career. I know a little, not much….but do recall his wife Bobbi (?) and could never determine what happened to his Brit car dealership, Oxford Motors.

        1. thanks for the info and photo…I have quite a few photos from various publications, but had not deen this one. He seemed to have competed in quite a variety of venues, mostly in California. As a boy, I only had the opportunity to see him compete twice, once in Vacaville in a Ferrari TR and once in an unoffical event in Santa Barbara in his 550. At the age of eight, I didn’t know much about those cars….one was silver, one was red…both were loud.

    1. Michelle,

      My father, Eldon Beagle, was a good friend of your father. They raced each other often in Central California. I have pictures of your father and at least two of his cars.

      1. Hi David, I just noticed your post…is the author , Michelle, the daughter of Sam Weiss? She must be younger than I, as I am pretty certain when they were our neighbors…they had no children? ( I couldn’t get a response in reply to her post )

  14. There he is, Sir STERLING MOSS, my friend and foe in the 1986 Bahama Vintage Grand Prix, where he drove his winning Aston DBR2 in the original ’59 Bahama Race. I was driving the 1957 Chevrolet Corvette powered Devon bodied ECHIDNA.
    I beat STERLING in the first race by fooling him at the start. Where upon he told me he would teach me Lesson #2 for race 2 the next day. Of course his lesson incorporated a technique to put his Aston in front of my Echidna while rounding the final turn before the flagman, and then hitting his breaks and standing on the gas simultaniously. Sterling had the pole and off he went with me trying to recover from hitting my breaks and losing RPM’s, and proving he was still the “BOSS”. I didn’t know until a month ago that Lesson #2 is a term referred to by the RAF Spitfire pilots of WW2, as “Technique” in dog fighting.
    So, it took 28 years for me to learn what the hell Sterling was talking about.

  15. We need people like you Ed. Do you happen to know the whereabouts of Bill Love? He drove this Sebring race together with Roy Jackson Moore and George Crowder in an AC Ace Bristol, car number 38. They came 22nd overall. I am fortunate to have Bill Loves car which is currently under restoration after spending 30 years in the California desert.
    Also, a well known lady driver who won a number of races in the car was Linda Scott. She was last heard of flying Planes for the Californian fire brigade. If anyone can put me in touch with her I would be really pleased.

    Ashley Wills

  16. Ashley, I am assuming that the Bill Love you mention is the man from Santa Cruz who racedLotus Elevens with his wife. That Bill Love died many years ago. He and his wife divorced and his cars were sold. One of his Elevens is now owned by Russ Hoenig. My friend Stewart Smith races an. Eleven now and lives in Santa Cruz and knows something about the Loves. I have forwarded you questions to them.

    1. Hi Robert. I was not aware Bill raced Lotus Elevens but he could well have done. I know that he and Linda Scott raced this AC Ace Bristol 39 times in the SCCA over 1957/58 winning I think 12 races and Linda winning a good number in class in both ladies and mixed. It will be interesting to see what Stewart can add and whether he knows anything about Linda. Cheers, Ashley.

      1. I was thinking of a fellow named “Jim Lowe” who lived in Santa Cruz and did race Elevens. So, different guy. But the name Bill Love seems to ring a bell and I might have seen him race in the late ’50’s if he was a Southern Calif racer. If he was friends with Frank Monise you might asked his son Frankie, who still runs the auto shop in Pasadena.

  17. I was at the 1958 race. I remember the purple corvette with the tapered piece behind the headrest,similar to the Jags. I often wonder what happened to it. It did’nt finish the race.It should have in the corvette museum. I also remember that Sterling Moss wore out his break pads and had to come in for a pad replacement, which took 16 sec. He then went out and run about 3 laps until the transmission failed.

  18. I was at Sebring I believe it was either 58 or 59 and Sterling was
    I was in Sebring I believe it was either 58 or 59 and Sterling was in his usual spor out in front. I watched in disbelief as he came around the hairpin turn and one of the workers or it could have been one of his crew, but they handed him a coke and when he came back around he gave him the empty back. I could not believe it. He was truly a great driver.

    1. Why are so many on here misspelling Stirling Moss’s name? Were he still with us he would not be pleased.

  19. In 1958 bought the Fiat Abarth Zagato driven by Jack Brumby at Sebring 1958. It was my transportation for many years, as well as my slalom cart. It sat dormant in my garage until last week when it was trucked to my son who’s going to restore it.

    1. Hi there – I am from Switzerlad and own car #80 (Abarth Zagato 750 GT) driven by Harry E Fry at 12h GP Sebring in 1958. Just in case you are interested in exchanging infos. Kind regards, Renald.

  20. Thanks. Great recap. My Dad’s 250TR (7020) ran as #14 the following year and finished 7th.
    Keep up this good work!